YouTube vs. Facebook for Music Video Releases: What’s Working For Me

Sage Harrington - Pyragraph

A still from one of our most recent music videos. Image courtesy of Sage Harrington.

This post was inspired by a conversation I had with a lovely person, audio engineer, and fellow Pyragraph writer Jamie Hill. (Check out his posts, now, please—I’ll wait here—you won’t regret it.)

His equally lovely wife, Shannon Curtis, is a musician who just kicks ass at Facebook. So Jamie suggested that I change the way I approach releasing videos online. Namely, that I release them natively through Facebook in addition to releasing them on YouTube.

Facebook, see, wants you to upload your videos through Facebook, and in order to do that they suppress YouTube links and boost Facebook video in your friends’/fans’ feeds. The moral of the story? More people will see your music video if you upload it through Facebook rather than posting a YouTube link to your Facebook page.

But not so fast, Ari Herstand might say. He’s written a post on this, which compares the way YouTube metrics work rather than the way that Facebook metrics work. Verdict? Facebook counts a view after three seconds of the video has run, and YouTube counts a view after about 30 seconds, meaning that a YouTube view essentially means more than a Facebook video view.

So what am I gonna do with all this info? Well, as much as I don’t like bending to what “the man” (er, that’s you, Mark Zuckerberg) I’m gonna be uploading my videos to Facebook, too. Because this:

Sage Harrington - Pyragraph

I do not kick ass at Facebook like Shannon Curtis does. She updates and updates and engages and engages with people and I mostly just want to stay away from the computer screen most of the time. (Here’s an example of Shannon Curtis kicking ass at Facebook video.) So the fact that we got over 70 shares (and a few of them were from people I don’t even know personally! Crikey!) when the most we had gotten before that was, like, three (and that was probably from from when I shared my own post through all my fb profiles/pages). So that’s a winner for me.

Here’s the downside:

Sage Harrington - Pyragraph

We are not getting as many views on YouTube now. We’re used to getting about 1000 views per video not long after we post them to…you guessed it…Facebook. We don’t have that many subscribers through YouTube and I only shared the link to this video through our email newsletter, once. I still think it’s important to have the video up on YouTube though. ( I just want it to keep getting the views we had been getting on YouTube.)

Moral of the story:

Uploading our music videos through Facebook page seems to be really working for us so far. I’ve never had so many conversations with people online about the cool stuff we make. We’ve never gotten so many comments on YouTube or our website or any other platform. And seeing people we don’t even know sharing our videos is pretty freaking exciting.

Sage Harrington

About Sage Harrington

Sage Harrington is a musician and Managing Editor for Pyragraph. She writes songs on her ukulele and plays them with her duo, Sage and Jared’s Happy Gland Band. They make videos and post them on the internet, while tending to their flock of urban chickens, two tiny dogs, and other small creatures.

1 Comment

  1. […] songs on Facebook is a royal pain. That’s why you see so many videos on YouTube that show a series of still photos or just a single […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.