The Musician and The Performer

Aaron J. Shay - Pyragraph

Seattle Acoustic Festival. Photo by Aaron J. Shay.

I recently attended and performed the Seattle Acoustic Festival, a small music festival focusing on the singer-songwriter genre. Many talented people were on the lineup, and also, me. I caught as many performances as I could. I consider it research, to see what else is going on in my field, and to make sure that what I’m doing is still distinct and memorable.

Rest assured, audience: I did not find any other banjoists singing about cyborgs, space travel or the apocalypse.

Telling truth doesn’t necessarily mean telling non-fiction.

However, this research did shed a clear light on something I’ve often thought about: the distinction between a musician and a performer.

The Musician

spends oh so much time perfecting the notes they will sing or play, and how to recover if a wrong note is hit. Their harmonies are crisp and precise. Their playing is thoughtful and intentional, no matter the instrument. This artist knows their scales, if not consciously, then intuitively. This artist is best described as methodical, insofar as they perform the songs.

The Performer

spends oh so much time considering how they play, and how they interact with an audience, and how to successfully play off of different audience moods. How do you have a good show when the audience is quiet and reserved? How do you have a good show when the audience is drunk and riotous? What’s the arch of your set list? Is there a story you’re trying to tell? What kind of onstage movement excites the crowd? These are the questions that they ask.

Anyone who knows me and my work probably can guess that I fall in the second category (yes, I know I need to practice my scales, I’M BUSY RIGHT NOW). But importantly, an artist can and probably should be both, to the best of their ability. Live performance is absolutely essential in today’s music world (for a variety of reasons not the purview of this article).

The festival I went to was rife with The Musician. The players were strong in their art, but when the art was done, there was often silence, or stilted banter. Many of the artists had not considered their role as The Performer. They had not considered the context of the show.

The singer-songwriter is an archetype in today’s music scene. It’s a culture with its own traditions, tropes, stereotypes and faux pas. It’s a muddy pool, full of conflicting ideas and hidden treasure. As artists, we must dive deep into our particular culture and examine every aspect we find at the bottom, then choose which ones we take with us back to the surface, and which ones we leave for others.

There is a style, an established format for a singer-songwriter’s performance: We tell stories related to the songs we sing. Tell a story, sing a song. Tell a story, sing a song. It’s what people expect. It’s what people are used to. We are earnest. We are truth-tellers. Three chords and the truth, sung at the local coffee shop after dark. There’s an established idea of what you’re supposed to be doing.

The song’s inspiration is often the least interesting part.

Since there’s an established idea, that means people have an expectation, and you can use that expectation as part of your art. You can distort it. You can reject it. You can play with it. An audience’s expectation of you is material you can shape, and you don’t have to follow the instruction booklet.

One of my favorite kinds of singer-songwriter right now is “The Angel Of Music Who Swears Like A Sailor.” Soaring, elegant and beautiful songs interspersed with saucy stories and dirty jokes. Mary Lambert and Eliza Rickman are great examples of this kind of artist; their performance style is a perfect counterpoint to their music. They embody both The Musician and The Performer.

I’ve taken a different approach. For me, telling truth doesn’t necessarily mean telling non-fiction. I write stories to accompany my work, or I write speeches regarding its subject, but only rarely do I discuss a song’s inspiration. That is often the least interesting part.

In the grand spectrum of singer-songwriters, I suppose I follow the traditions of The Truth Teller, but in the words of Emily Dickinson, I tell it slant; after all, the truth can come in many forms. And I gravitate towards forms of the truth that involve dragons and space ships.

How do you play with the traditions of your art form? Do you tweak them, follow them, distort them, reject them? Let me know in the comments below.

Aaron J. Shay

About Aaron J. Shay

Aaron J. Shay  is a writer, performer, and musician from the Pacific Northwest. An active and independent recording artist, Shay has self- and co-produced 8 EPs since 2010, some for his own projects and some for his friends and collaborators. More recently, he has been active in theater, writing/producing two one-man singer-songwriter shows, and also serving as musical director for fringe productions. Shay currently lives in Seattle, WA, where he doesn’t mind the weather.

1 Comment

  1. Josh L. on September 8, 2016 at 11:49 am

    I went to middle school with Jason Garfield, who was an amazingly good technical juggler even then. But as a street performer, he was kind of terrible. He clearly knew what audiences expected of a street juggler, and hated having to play to those expectations. He has since founded the World Juggling Federation, an organization dedicated to juggling as a competitive sport rather than a performing art. I can respect that; in the absence of the equivalent of a studio musician role for his field, he created one.

    I’m kind of going the same way myself; by gravitating towards contra and square dance bands, I get to hand off a lot of the navigation of the audience/performer interface to someone else. I still have to pay attention to the energy of the room and respond, but nobody at a square dance cares about where a dance tune came from, they just care that it’s danceable. And the caller deals with everything else.

    I’ve got a lot of respect for those who can balance the Musician and Performer aspects. It seems like the one requires an inner focus, while the other requires an external focus. Being able to balance that, or shift back and forth, does not look easy.

Leave a Reply